Changeset: 140738530
Adding features, changing geometry+tags to try and clarify where bikes and pedestrians are allowed on the West River Parkway Trail
Closed by gvwaal
Tags
changesets_count | 270 |
---|---|
created_by | iD 2.27.1 |
host | https://www.openstreetmap.org/edit |
imagery_used | Hennepin County Orthoimagery (2021) |
locale | en-US |
resolved:outdated_tags:incomplete_tags | 3 |
source | survey;aerial imagery |
Discussion
-
Comment from jumbanho
Thanks for improving the mapping of the trails along the river. I think some of the parts of the main trail where you have two separate ways (one cycleway and one footway) may actually be better represented as one way using cycleway=yes, foot=designated, segregated=yes as noted on the wiki: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:segregated
-
Comment from gvwaal
Hi jumbanho, it's cool to find someone interested in the same things I am! Just so we're on the same page, you're talking about how I split footpaths out from the cycleway, like how way#911885632 diverges from way#911885631 near the intersection of 38th Ave S and West River Parkway?
If you are, I began splitting out footpaths approximately where the paths diverge in reality. Where the footpath is directly attached to the cycleway, separated only by paint, I tried to preserve a single way with highway=cycleway+bicycle=designated+foot=designated+segregated=yes; and where the footpath diverges, separated from the cycleway by soil, I tagged the footpath as highway=footway+bicycle=no and the cycleway as highway=cycleway+foot=no. Not only are the paths literally separated, that's also what the path markings specify.
In this specific example, the segregated=yes tag is unnecessary on the cycleway north of this intersection, and I see how that may be confusing. I'll need to remove it from the paths I edited.
- 1204548374, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548375), v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548376), v1
- 1204548377, v1
- 1204548378, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548379), v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548380), v1
- 1204548381, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548382), v1
- 1204548383, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548384), v1
- 1204548385, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548386), v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548387), v1
- 1204548388, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548389), v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548390), v1
- 1204548391, v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548392), v1
- West River Parkway Trail (1204548393), v1
Relations (6)
- Grand Rounds National Scenic Byway (1749619), v151
- Mississippi River Byway District (1750680), v18
- Mississippi River Trail (Minnesota) (2175906), v434
- Winchell Trail (10014695), v5
- 20 (Minnesota) (13984302), v32
- 45 (15976701), v13
- 11163979414, v1
- 11163979415, v1
- 11163979416, v1
- 11163979417, v1
- 11163979418, v1
- 11163979419, v1
- 11163979420, v1
- 11163979421, v1
- 11163979422, v1
- 11163979423, v1
- 11163979424, v1
- 11163979425, v1
- 11163979426, v1
- 11163979427, v1
- 11163979428, v1
- 11163979429, v1
- 11163979430, v1
- 11163979431, v1
- 11163979432, v1
- 11163979433, v1
Welcome to OpenStreetMap!
OpenStreetMap is a map of the world, created by people like you and free to use under an open license.
Hosting is supported by Fastly, OSMF corporate members, and other partners.
https://openstreetmap.org/copyright | https://openstreetmap.org |
Copyright OpenStreetMap and contributors, under an open license |